Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Good but not that good. The green lights won't last

HOW do we follow up a week like that? For months the economic data here and abroad has been all red and amber lights. Then suddenly we get a wave of green lights, all at once, that seems to clear away the blockages and open up a clear path ahead.

An interest rate cut on Tuesday was followed by the Bureau of Statistics reporting unbelievably strong GDP growth and a sustained rebound in jobs. Then the rest of the world waved us on: China cut its interest rates and announced huge export growth, and European finance ministers agreed to lend Spain up to 100 billion euro($A125 billion) to prevent the collapse of its banks.

If only every week was like that. Then Wayne Swan and the Pollyanna chorus would always be right, confidence would never be short and there would be no point in reading (or writing) columns on economics.

But we know that things are not that simple. We don't usually get waves of green lights sweeping us past every intersection. Good data behind us even if it survives the revisions does not guarantee good times ahead. It's certainly welcome, but while it eases the problems facing Australia and the world in the next 18 months, it does not remove them.

For Australia, the next big test is the introduction of the carbon tax on July 1, along with $2.4 billion of handouts to households in compensation and the school kids bonus. That will be a test of the hyper-emotional, hyper-negative tone that suffocates political debate in these times. Influential forces are trying to derail the tax, and would not mind if they derailed the economy as well.

For Europe, the next big test will be Sunday's Greek election, and the negotiations that will follow, whoever wins, to either rewrite Europe's fiscal austerity pact or remove Greece from the eurozone. At this stage, everyone is taking positions to try to influence the election result. What will happen after it is anyone's guess; the stakes are immense.

Take Australia first. At face value, last week's GDP figures tell us the economy is powering ahead, propelled by robust consumer spending (up 4.2 per cent in a year), quite extraordinary growth in engineering construction (up 53 per cent in that time), strong growth in payrolls (7.4 per cent) and productivity (4 per cent) and booms in sectors from finance to government administration, healthcare, the professions, wholesale trade and agriculture.

Most of that is probably broadly true, if overstated. As I reported on May 11, the Bureau of Statistics has run into technical problems with its jobs data, leading it to overstate jobs growth in 2010 and understate it in 2011 and 2012. Federal and state tax collections confirm that actual job growth has been stronger than the bureau figures show. And that means the economy has also grown more strongly than we thought.

Healthcare and the professions are growth industries. The farmers have had a lot of rain, wholesalers have had a lot of imports. The big banks are shedding staff, but they are also losing market share to smaller banks and non-bank lenders. And migration figures imply that population growth is accelerating.

But there are serious question marks over the two drivers of growth. Growth in consumer spending actually slowed, yet the bureau says that prices have stopped rising, so we've actually hit the pedal to buy more and more. Tell that to High Street.

Even more amazing, it says engineering construction costs are almost flat, despite the mining boom: in the past 3 years they have risen 1.8 per cent (0.5 per cent a year), a sharp change after 24.8 per cent growth in the previous 3 years. Tell that to the Pilbara.

The GDP numbers are likely to be revised down, but to still fairly buoyant levels. The central problem remains: mining is booming while south-eastern Australia is not. In the year to March, spending grew by 10 per cent in the resource states but only 2 per cent in the south-east. The dollar, after three months of welcome falls, has bounced back up to nudge parity with the US dollar. And, like everyone else, our growth depends on what happens in Europe.

The rescue of the Spanish banks buys time for Europe's leaders to negotiate a growth pact, then either exempt Greece from its budget constraints or push it out of the eurozone and risk the fear and uncertainty that would create.

It was a good week for us, and the world, but there are rough times ahead. The best thing is that we are entering this period in stronger shape than we thought. And more than most countries, we are able to make our own fortune.